particular historical circumstances and with given person, place and time. With the advent of the printed book grammatica surged back to a dominance it had enjoyed before scholasticism and the moderni and the new universities had swept it aside. Scholasticism in ancient Rome was also an oral affair, and Bonner points out Cicero’s letter to Atticus in which Cicero mentions a list of theses which he himself declaimed in private: They are almost exclusively concerned with the subject of tyrants and tyranny—‘Should one work for the tyrant’s downfall, even though it may jeopardize the State, or merely prevent his overthrower’s elevation?’ . . . ‘Should one attempt to help one’s country, when subject to a tyrant, by opportune speech rather than by force of arms?’ There are eight such subjects, which Cicero says